By Melinda Kee, SOS Save Our Super
I have spent the past year fighting for one outcome for First Guardian and Shield victims. Get as much of their retirement savings back as possible. Not a percentage if 100 per cent is achievable. Not a settlement that looks impressive before costs are taken out. The maximum amount possible back into the hands of the people who lost it.
That is why I continue to question whether the current class actions against Macquarie and Netwealth are really in the best financial interests of the majority of investors.
I am not saying there is no legal case against the trustees. There may very well be, and there are important questions about trustee responsibility that deserve to be tested. But having a legal case that can be run and having a case that produces the best outcome for investors are two very different things.
My question is simple. What pathway puts the most money back into the investor’s pocket?
Macquarie and Netwealth investors have already had their net investment returned. What many investors are now seeking is their additional “but for” loss. In simple terms, to place the consumer in the financial position they would be in if the financial adviser had provided appropriate financial advice.
For many investors, those losses may be capable of being pursued through a free AFCA complaint against the financial advice firm or licensee responsible for the advice; blame should also fall on the Licencee. Where an eligible AFCA determination remains unpaid because the financial firm is insolvent, the CSLR may provide compensation up to its $150,000 cap.
AFCA is free. There is no litigation funder taking a percentage and no legal bill deducted from the investor’s compensation simply for using AFCA.
So before anybody tells these investors that a class action is the answer, I want to see the maths.
Take an investor who had $300,000 invested. Show them their estimated “but for” loss. Show them what they may recover through AFCA and, if eligible, the CSLR. Then show them what they might recover through the class action after any settlement discount, litigation funding costs, legal costs and the years of uncertainty that can come with litigation.
That is the comparison that matters.
This concern is serious enough that I have taken it to regulators
I recently wrote to the Legal Services Commissioner, the Attorney General, ASIC, AFCA and the office of Assistant Treasurer and Minister for Financial Services Dr Daniel Mulino raising concerns about whether affected investors are being given enough information about the different pathways available to them.
I did not accuse Gordon Legal of professional misconduct. I asked whether the circumstances warranted investigation and, in particular, whether the lead applicant was properly informed about the AFCA pathway before agreeing to lead the Macquarie class action.
There is an important history behind that question.
Gordon Legal approached me last year about becoming involved in a proposed class action, This was done via a third Party making contact with me on the page. I had an approximately one-hour conversation with them and made my position very clear. I specifically raised AFCA and the CSLR and explained why I believed investors should understand these free compensation pathways before being encouraged towards litigation.
My concern then is exactly the same as it is today. Before you potentially take a percentage of someone’s recovery through litigation, first establish whether that person has a free pathway capable of compensating their loss.
Then I spoke to the lead applicant
On 17 September 2026, I had a direct Messenger conversation with the lead applicant in the Macquarie class action, Rachelle Dessent.
I asked whether she had lodged an AFCA complaint. Her answer was “No.”
When I asked why, she told me:
“I have a new advisor now, he didn’t say I could/should file a complaint.”
I explained that she may still be able to lodge an AFCA complaint. She responded that she would “get onto” it.
Earlier in our conversation she had also said:
“Whatever they get me, I wouldn’t have got back anyway.”
I want to be very clear about what I am saying here. I do not know what Gordon Legal privately advised Rachelle. I have not seen her retainer, costs agreement, correspondence or legal advice, and Gordon Legal disputes the suggestion that she was unaware of AFCA.
That is precisely why I asked the regulator to establish the facts rather than making accusations.
Was the lead applicant told that she may have a separate AFCA complaint concerning the financial advice she received? Was the possibility of a complaint against the responsible licensee explained? Was the potential CSLR pathway explained? If so, when was that information provided and was it before she agreed to become the lead applicant?
I think those are fair questions.
Then the information on Gordon Legal’s website changed
I also reviewed archived versions of Gordon Legal’s website.
The version I reviewed from 27 July 2026 mentioned AFCA in general terms. However, it did not contain the much more detailed information that appeared later explaining complaints involving financial advisers, insolvent advice firms and the CSLR.
By 24 September 2026, shortly after my conversation with Rachelle and media attention around this issue, that information had been substantially expanded.
The website now included the words:
“Some Shield investors may not know that they can complain…”
It also made clear that the class action was against Macquarie and not the financial planners who may have advised people to invest in Shield.
I am not suggesting that my conversation or the media coverage caused Gordon Legal to change its website. I have no evidence of why or when the decision to expand that information was made.
But I do think the change is relevant.
In fact, I welcome the additional information because this is exactly what I have been arguing investors needed to understand from the beginning.
The investors are telling us what they think

When I raised the class action issue publicly, the response from affected investors was overwhelming.
One investor wrote:
“Do not sign up unless you get nothing when going through AFCA.”
Another said:
“I don’t think anyone should be pursuing class actions.”
Another simply said:
“I would be opting out.”
Perhaps the comment that concerned me most came from an investor who said they had participated in the Dixon class action:
“We signed up to the Dixon class action and got back approx 10% after lawyers fees.”
That is one investor’s reported experience and should not be taken as evidence of what will happen in these class actions. But it shows exactly why people are nervous.
Another investor asked a question that goes directly to the heart of the issue:
“How is it possible that I am a part of this class action when I didn’t give permission to represent me?”
That confusion matters because Australian class actions generally operate on an opt out basis. People who fall within the class definition can be group members without individually signing up, unless they opt out when the Court provides the opportunity.
These investors have already lived through a financial disaster they did not properly understand. They should not now find themselves confused about another process involving their retirement savings.
I am not saying AFCA and the class action are the same
This distinction is important.
Gordon Legal argues that the class action concerns Macquarie’s responsibilities as trustee, while an AFCA complaint may concern the conduct of an adviser or financial services licensee. Those are different legal claims and potentially different responsible parties.
I accept that. But different does not automatically mean better.
If an investor can recover their remaining loss through an AFCA complaint against the party responsible for their financial advice, why should that investor not fully understand and investigate that pathway before deciding whether litigation is financially worthwhile?
Likewise, an investor with a very large loss, someone outside the CSLR eligibility requirements or someone whose loss cannot be adequately recovered through AFCA may reach a completely different conclusion.
Our information shows this only applies to a handful of investors who were on a platform overseen by a trustee. The majority of investors with large balances were advised to open a SMSF. The class actions do not apply to them.
That is why I am not telling every investor to opt out of a class action. I am saying ‘do the maths’ and remember the lawyers are there to negotiate… they may settle for 40-60% of what you are owed, then start the deductions…
Understand the numbers first.
This is their retirement money
These people have already trusted advisers, licensees, trustees, platforms and a financial system that was supposed to protect their retirement savings.
What we now know is that each one of these gate keepers failed them.
They should not have to blindly trust another process.
I am not interested in whether a class action creates an important legal precedent if the individual investor ends up financially worse off. I am not interested in the headline value of a settlement if a significant amount disappears before reaching the people who actually lost their money.
I want to know the net amount the investor receives.
If the class action genuinely delivers more, show us.
If AFCA and the CSLR potentially deliver more for a particular investor, tell them that too.
Give people the facts, give them the numbers and allow them to make an informed decision.
This is not about being anti lawyer and it is certainly not about protecting Macquarie, Netwealth, advisers or anybody else who may be responsible. Every party responsible for this disaster should be held accountable.
But accountability must also deliver the best possible outcome for victims.
My position remains simple.
If an investor may be able to recover their remaining loss through a free AFCA complaint and, where eligible, the CSLR, why would they knowingly accept less through years of litigation after funding and legal costs?
Maybe there is a good answer for some investors. I am still waiting to hear from an actual investor about how they will be better off.
People have already lost enough. The next process should be about making them whole, not taking another slice of their retirement savings.
Let’s look at the Maths.
- After 1 year: $24,000
- After 2 years (simple): $48,000.
Melinda Kee
SOS Save Our Super, Investor Advocacy
This article represents my opinion and is intended to encourage investors to understand their options. It is not legal or financial advice. Every investor’s circumstances are different, and independent advice should be obtained before making a decision about AFCA or a class action.
